Introduction
Caffeine is everywhere and it is not only in coffee and soda. Energy drinks are increasing in popularity and youth athletes have been seen with them frequently. Youth athletes may ask for energy drinks because they see their friends drinking them, or because they think they will provide them with more “energy” for sports and school. Let’s explore if caffeine is safe for youth athletes. This blog will cover how caffeine can impact performance and caffeine’s impact on a kid’s health.
Caffeine and youth athletes: What is Caffeine?
Simply put, caffeine stimulates the activity of your brain and central nervous system. It is found in coffee, energy drinks, some sports gels, teas and chocolate. According to research, there is no safe amount of coffee for kids under 11. The American Academy of child and adolescent psychiatry states that children 12-18 should keep their consumption of caffeine to under 100 mg/day and the academy of pediatrics states that there is no safe amount of caffeine in the diets of children and adolescents. This means that athletes under 11 should definitely not be consuming caffeine containing energy drinks or coffee and those 12-18 should avoid them as well.
You may be surprised to learn how much caffeine some beverages contain. The website Caffeine Informer allows you to check how much caffeine popular beverages contain. For example, when I typed in Celsius which is a popular energy drink I see high school athletes drink, I learned that it contains 200 mg/12 oz. It is important to note that amounts will vary per different brands and types of caffeinated drinks.
Some examples of what 12 oz of caffeinated drinks include:
- Caffeinated soda 23-83 mg
- Green tea 37 mg
- Black tea 71 mg
- Coffee 113 -247 mg
- Energy drinks 41-246 mg
What are energy drinks?
While often confused for one another, energy drinks and sports drinks are NOT the same thing. Energy drinks contain stimulants such as caffeine as a way to boost energy. According to the CDC, energy drinks contain large amounts of caffeine, added sugar, other additives and stimulants such as guarana, taurine, and L-carnitine. These stimulants in addition to caffeine, can increase alertness, attention, and energy as well as increase blood pressure, heart rate and breathing. While often chosen to help with energy and alertness, lets not forget potential side effects that will be discussed more below.
Two important distinctions between energy drinks and sports drinks are:
- Energy drinks DO NOT replenish nutrients lost in sweat through prolonged activity
- Energy drinks contain a stimulant such as caffeine which acts as a diuretic which can lead to dehydration with prolonged exercise in kids
Some sports drink brands market both sports drinks and energy drinks to kids making it confusing. Be sure to always read all labels, and avoid anything that contains caffeine or other stimulants for youth athletes.
Risks of Caffeine for Youth Athletes
There are many risks associated with caffeine intake in youth athletes. A study published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal showed that more than half of children (ages 12-17) and young adults (ages 18-24) have had adverse effects from caffeinated drinks and energy drinks. While this study was done outside of the US, all of the same risks of caffeine are shown here.
Risks that have been seen with caffeine intake in youth athletes include:
- Impaired sleep
- Increased feelings of anxiety
- Risk of dehydration
- Increased heart rate
- Increased blood pressure
- Gastrointestinal complaints
These potential negative side effects in turn can interfere with an athlete’s ability to perform. For example, an athlete that feels restless and has impaired sleep will not have the energy they need and will also be at a bigger risk of injury due to exhaustion. Youth athletes are still growing, and more research is also needed on how caffeine impacts developing nervous systems and cardiovascular systems.
Alternatives to Caffeine for Performance Enhancement
If your youth athlete thinks they need caffeine and/or energy drinks to boost their energy and athletic performance, it is important to find out why. Paying attention to their diet, hydration and their sleep habits could help them find the energy they need! Enough sleep, a balanced diet, and eating at the right times can help. Scheduling an appointment with a youth sports dietitian can help to evaluate if any nutrients are missing in their diet, and help get them on a plan to meet their nutrition needs, hydration goals and eat at the right times to boost their performance. If an energy boost is needed during a game, reach for simple carbohydrates such as pretzels, graham crackers, fruit, dried fruit, fig bars or sports drinks. For more ideas, see some of my other blog posts on pre and post game fueling.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is important to discourage the use of caffeine and energy drinks for youth athletes. Coaches and parents should educate their players about the potential risks, and work with professionals to help discover why players feel these are needed in the first place. As a youth sports dietitian, I am able to educate teams on this topic and many more. Reach out to me at Sports Nutrition 4 Kids. Do you have players on your team that reach for caffeine and energy drinks? Comment below!
